By Joseph J. Collins ( Institute for National Strategic Studies) Reviewed by Amb. (ret.) Michael Cotter ( Vice. (This is a National Defense University study paper on the Iraq war. It opens “Measured in. NDU Press of INSS publishes books, monographs, reports, and occasional papers on national and international security affairs, defense policy, and military .

Author: Goltishura Gardakree
Country: Bangladesh
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Automotive
Published (Last): 4 June 2011
Pages: 173
PDF File Size: 11.76 Mb
ePub File Size: 15.32 Mb
ISBN: 958-2-90825-387-2
Downloads: 5398
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Migar

Just like in Vietnam, our military won the war, what we lost was the peace.

Pentagon institute call Iraq war “a major debacle”

April in Off-Topic Discussion. The report carries considerable weight because it was written by Joseph Collins, a former senior Pentagon official, and was based in part on interviews with other former senior defense and intelligence officials who played roles in prewar preparations.

Bush cooked it up and pretty much all of Congress signed off on it. Topics US news Opinion. In every case, assumptions are affected by wishful opp5, stress, predispositions of the key actors, uncertainty, and the process used to arrive at decisions.

Series – Center for Security Studies | ETH Zurich

For him, there were real dividends to be gained by letting his enemies believe occzsional_papers possessed WMD, whether it was true or not. Links will not be permitted.

Our National Security Council staff, Cabinet departments, and especially our Congress have not yet adapted to the demanding requirements of 21 st -century complex contingencies.

If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons! Rumsfeld, who was closely allied with Vice President Dick Cheney, bypassed the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the report says, and became “the direct supervisor of the combatant commanders.

Newsmax, Moneynews, Newsmax Health, and Independent. Always remember, however sure you are that you can easily win, that there would not be a war if the occasional_pzpers man did not think that he also had a oo5.

These initial assumptions were a thread that ran through many missteps, and thus it is important to ask where assumptions come from. As i have said previously about my thoughts on government, it is up to the leader to surround himself with people intelligent enough in their relevant fields to make informed decissions.


Keep discussions on topic, avoid personal attacks and threats of any kind. The people who ended up with egg on their faces were not the Bush administration or the Pentagon – though Donald Rumsfeld, in the transcripts, was as cynical and dislikeable as ever – but the generals who bought into the Pentagon’s spin and the networks who employed them. The addition of 30, U. Even with the improvement in security brought on by the surge, the war in Iraq is still considered a failure in just about every way says a report from the National Defence University.

What disgusted occasionap_papers, by contrast, was that while this well-oiled effort was underway in America, our strategic communications efforts in Iraq and the greater Middle East remained bumbling and inept.

insss Now come on, the election was not that long ago. The chapter “Errors in decisionmaking and execution” had a nice little summary. Order by newest oldest recommendations.

Trump Says Partial U. That whole document reads like a list of Government occaasional_papers in the decission to go to war, and i must admit i am rather surprised to see you post it As the lead key judgment in the.

I dont believe its agenda driven, such as the headlines in the newspapers and tv. Bob Bateman, an active-duty US army officer and respected military historian, noted on the blog Small Wars Journal that several of the generals profiled in the Times article – notably, Barry McCaffrey and Robert Scales – have been among the fiercest and most intelligent critics of the war effort despite the Pentagon’s efforts to woo them.

Give a fish a man and inss will eat for a month! I didn’t vote for Bush either, but chances are if you vote, you voted for people that were for this crap. To me it just seems to strengthen the argument that the Iraq was was a product of incompetency. Neither of these things gets much mention in US history textbooks.

In conclusion, the war in Iraq and its aftermath have exposed a.

Choosing war: the decision to invade Iraq and its aftermath

I take offense to him being the patsy in this debacle. As for the National Defense University, I guess we should just hang it up and pull out now that they have finally chimed in. During occasional_paperz first world war, the first neoconservative, President Woodrow Wilson, imprisonedAmericans for making “disloyal” statements during wartime.


That said, the potential for excess on the part of the government is readily apparent, and checks on abuse of power must be firmly established.

Speculation about what people may have believed is useless. They were either deceitful or entirely incompetent, although im still not entirely sure which is better. Originally posted by unconformed im not sure what you mean by stuff-ups so i am a little lost to how to take your comment.

We now know that there were many holes in our knowledge base, but senior officials and analysts were almost universally united in their core beliefs. One hopes that, for all of.

Choosing war: the decision to invade Iraq and its | Pritzker Military Museum & Library | Chicago

Rise of the Fallen. Newsmax Comment Policy Keep discussions on topic, avoid personal attacks and threats of any kind. In short, pretty much everyone believed he had ambitions of having WMD but they did not simply assume he had a meaningful weapons program. Shroud of the Avatar. These elder statesmen and the erstwhile media “watchdogs” completely abandoned their critical thinking skills.

He was selected by the people he’s making rich at the moment. Baghdad has chemical and biological weapons as well as missiles with ranges in excess of UN restrictions; if left unchecked, it probably will have a nuclear weapon during this decade.

Infor example, when the US mistakenly and horrifically targeted a wedding party in Iraq, killing 40 innocent people, the spokesman inws Iraq at the time lamely insisted that “bad people have parties too.